Remove arrow buff from bow, remove bow stagger, and find a better way than forums

[Nabrious]

@ AGS moderators…

My point has been proven, I have posted a clear and concise post of my thoughts on an issue. In response… the vast majority of responses have come from loud “forum dwellers” who spend more time on the forums than the game, and so have little experience of which they speak on. THIS is why the vast majority of your game’s population do not post on the forums, because they are bullied off the forums by these “forum dwellers” who thrive on berating, and bullying actual well thought out posters.

To all of the forums dwellers I say this: You are loved, I know you have been hurt, and so you seek to feel better by inflicting that same hurt upon others. An eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind. Seek to be better. Use the pain you feel as a motivator for betterment of self, not for inflating your ego.

[Nabrious]

Edited* this post due to the post I responded to having a racist comment and thus being removed.

[gothshorty]

@Nabrious

Yes I know bow only has 1 stagger left. If you read my post I stated exactly this and that the last remaining stagger on bow needs to be removed.

No. Bows that run evade shot are fighting close to the fight, and should have at least one self peel with it.

@Nabrious

The problem is bow was given a massive buff, which was the projectile size and hitbox. Every other ranged attack must actually be aimed at and hit the actual character box. Bow however has a hitbox larger than the actual character.

The hitbox literally got nerfed and has the smallest hitbox in the game currently regarding projectiles, outside of musket (which is a mess rn) you actually do have to aim the bow however, and it takes a lot of practice to get used to arrow drop, and how to lead your shots effectively. The fact you’re saying “every other ranged attack must be aimed and hit the actual character box” shows me that you’ve never played any other ranged in the game, let alone bow.

@Nabrious

Additionally bow arrows have insanely large hitboxes, the largest in the game. So large that arrows can be seen to have a HOMING ability where the arrow tracer animations actually will curve 180° to hit their target. So if anything, bows have aimbot, certainly not healers. What a joke you are.

Again, just a blatant lie. The arrow hit boxes just got nerfed and are currently the smallest hitbox outside of musket. There is no homing. You have 0 bow knowledge and shouldn’t be listened to. The curve you see is a latency issue. It’s the animation catching up with the damage. You were already hit by the arrow and the animation is catching up because of a ping difference. It can show it on your screen and not on theirs. To say bows have aimbot makes me think you’re just trolling at this point.

[Nabrious]

You came into my thread to clown me. Your first post was literally just asking why I am posting to the forums. Now that I’ve exposed the clown that you are, and now that your rage post was removed for a racist comment, now you want to pretend you’re here to debate me about my topic.

No thanks.

I have videos to prove my points, you do not. Show me the video proving bow has the smallest hitbox in the game right now. I’ll wait.

Added photo for comedic value*

[gothshorty]

I never once made a racist comment wtf you’re confusing me with someone else 100%. This is my third reply to your thread.

Also you don’t need video proof. Just read the patch notes lmao. Every other heavy projectile is 0.33, bow is 0.275 now. Skills too. Light attacks are 0.15, which is the same for other light projectiles if I’m not mistaken. Magic actually might have bigger light projectiles, not too sure tho.

[Nabrious]

You will not gaslight me. I know what happened. I know what I read.

You’re in denial and the fact that you keep responding to my thread means I have struck a chord with you. You do need video proof as not everything goes into the patch notes especially stuff like projectile size and hitboxes and net framework processing.

edit: the forums will be pulled down eventually, they announced discord as their next primary means of feedback. So I will no longer be responding to your nonsense.

~I have spoken.~

[gothshorty]

Ok, never said anything racist or got a post removed you don’t have to respond, no one is taking you seriously anyway.

Btw, they literally put the projectile sizes in the patch notes and the data is out there. Up to you if you choose to believe or not, irdc lol

[Glorfinhel]

Lets debunk your own post shall we, as you seem to ignore every response to your own questions and continue to ignore reasonable arguments.

@Nabrious

With 200 con, all the buffs from housing and gear you can almost reach 13K health as a light healer.

Correct, without ANY armor on, no protection… the arrow shot on your screenshot deals 64.73% damage to you. (calculated with exactly 13000 health) Like any headline, thats misleading and overdramatic, which is what I am guessing you are after by the looks of it.

Here is you contradicting yourself:

@Nabrious

If you actually read my post and viewed my screen shot you will see I am complaining about the damage being done WITH ALL defenses taken into account.

Wrong, it does not take 65% (64.73%) of your health in one shot, it takes 33.7% (13k health) WITH ALL defenses taken into account.

You asked:

@Glorfinhel

@Nabrious

You’re also contradicting yourself here quite a bit in the same sentence you say its quite a bit of damage, but not OP. Tell me how that works please.

How so? - bows do a lot of damage, as they are supposed to. Arrows can be easily dodged and in some cases predicted with shots which means you have a larger opportunity to get out of the way, the high damage compensates for that. Which does not make it OP but in line with other weapons and their opportunities.

And to a reasonable answer, you attempt again to ignore it and respond with… what?

@Nabrious

Additionally, if you are taking damage and getting staggered by melee, it is 100% a skill issue, learn to use your shift key properly and you will not have those issues.
You seem like a bow enjoyer who used to heal, trying to defend bow’s base dmg from getting nerfed. Coping will not save you or this game. Facing facts and taking appropriate action will.

@Nabrious

I rest my case on you being a bow enjoyer, you have proved my point exactly by stating your bow skill is “still” at 19. You are here on the forums speaking to a healer with over 4000 hours of pvp healing experience, yet here you are still a lvl 19 bow speaking on behalf of bow skills and abilities arguing with me. How foolish.

First you state that I dont have the skill to outmatch CC and bow users by simply using my shift key, and then telling me I am not a healer. And THEN you argue that Thats exactly my point, you dont know anything about bow because you are not a bow user - Werent you saying you were a 4000 hour healer? Oh yes, here it is:

@Nabrious

You are here on the forums speaking to a healer with over 4000 hours of pvp healing experience, yet here you are still a lvl 19 bow speaking on behalf of bow skills and abilities arguing with me. How foolish.

Why are you making suggestions to bow as a 4000 hour healer? hmm?

---

You also said:

@Nabrious

Additionally, if you are taking damage and getting staggered by melee, it is 100% a skill issue, learn to use your shift key properly and you will not have those issues.

You are here complaining about 1 user shooting you, I said 2 in combination would take me down if played right with CCs… who has the skill issue? Learn to use your shift key properly and you will not have those issues.

@Nabrious

My point has been proven, I have posted a clear and concise post of my thoughts on an issue.

lmao

[T0ru]

@Nabrious

It is ludicrous that a bow has the potential to hit for 8,400 damage in one arrow (NON CRIT)

Show me this mythological, out of space, 5 infinity stone bow that u talk of.

Btw what’s ur gear score?

[igor.castro.nogueira]

@Nabrious

The problem is bow was given a massive buff, which was the projectile size and hitbox

Yeah, i was always against this.

@Nabrious

Every other ranged attack must actually be aimed at and hit the actual character box. Bow however has a hitbox larger than the actual character

You’re wrong, actually bow USED to have the same hitbox as firestaff, now firestaff has a larger hitbox New World Mythbusters - Bow vs Firestaff Common Myths Debunked - YouTube , youc an test it for yourself.

@Nabrious

1 good DPS should not be able to kill 1 good healer on their own. This would render healers useless, because what is the point if a healer cannot out-heal the damage of 1 DPS?

First part is your opnion, and i’m completely against it. And no, if a DPS can kill a healer by himself it just means that a healer can no longer facetank somebody and now has to position himself/herself BETTER in order to survive. Healers aren’t suposed to be a solo class, i’m not saying you should be easy to kill. It’s perfectly balanced in the game right now, where if you play like a potato you’ll be dead.

@Nabrious

can show you many videos of me dodging arrows and melee, I know how to use my shift key The issue is I cannot dodge projectiles I cannot see

You can see arrows and other projectiles tho (every ranged weapon that isn’t musket) ,so i don’t see what’s your point here.

@Nabrious

and thus I should not be staggered by something I cannot defend against.

It makes 0 sense, i mean if I choose to walk just pressing W in the middle of the battlefield and an entire ranged or mage party is in my back I shouldn’t take as much damage? LOL i mean that’s the whole point of positioning yourself better. Just admit bro, you’re missing playing like a BOT and surviving.

@Nabrious

That is mainly for unskilled pvpers or for pve’rs who want a brainless experience

Hence most healers?

@Nabrious

dditionally bow arrows have insanely large hitboxes, the largest in the game.

New World Mythbusters - Bow vs Firestaff Common Myths Debunked

[igor.castro.nogueira]

You’re right, just linked the video to prove it.

It doesn’t matter to him tho. He’s just missing imortality while standing his green circle.

Guess finally healers will need to learn how to play the game, I LOVE IT

[Kippp]

The old hit box was huge. You cannot deny that. I haven’t had the chance to check the new one.

If they simply required the bow and fire staff to actually hit the character model to do damage it would solve a lot of issues. It would make the weapon less viable for people who just spam attacks and it would raise the skill ceiling.

New World 2023 04 20 12 39 30 09

[igor.castro.nogueira]

This is not bow and firestaff we’re talking about. you made the only unfair comparison beetween bow and another weapon which is Throwing hatchet. Every other ranged weapon had the same hitbox at least on heavy atacks.

What was wrong about the bow was a passive that granted aditional hitboxes (unintentionaly) which was fixed 6 months ago. NOW bow has actually a lower hitbox than any other ranged weapon (if we’re talking about heavy atacks)

Even then you could argue that throwing hatchet should have a lower hitbox, since hatchet is a melee weapon and can be useful in very close quarters combat, bow and firestaff cannot, well they can but not as good as a hatchet.

Also, there’s a problem with bow’s crosshair that makes it so your shot goes slighty to to left where you’re aiming at (sadly still true in this live update) if you made the same test aiming to the right, instead of the left you would see different results.

I know throwing hatchet has a lower hitbox, but it’s not that different if you aim to the left of the target.

Then again, the video you posted is throwing hatchet against bow HEAVIES. I don’t need to tell you that throwing a hatchet is way faster than charging a heavy. the comparison should be throwing hatchet against bow’s LIGHT atack, which has lower hitbox and faster shooting speed, just like the hatchet.

[Kippp]

@igor.castro.nogueira

This is not bow and firestaff we’re talking about. you made the only unfair comparison beetween bow and another weapon which is Throwing hatchet. Every other ranged weapon had the same hitbox at least on heavy atacks.

It shouldn’t matter if it’s heavy or light attacks. You should have to always hit the character model.

You don’t even need to hit the character model with the bow or fire staff. No one would be okay with that in a competitive PvP game.

You have to hit the character model with the musket and hatchet.

The spear might have a generous hit box with javelin, but I haven’t really tested it.

[igor.castro.nogueira]

@Kippp

It shouldn’t matter if it’s heavy or light attacks. You should have to always hit the character model.

But it does LOL heavies takes longer to charge have extended hitboxes and damage, while lights don’t. So a more accurate comparison would compare bow’s lights and throwing hatchets light, since it doesn’t have a heavy atack mode, and it shoots way faster than a heavy bow atack.

@Kippp

You don’t even need to hit the character model with the bow or fire staff. No one would be okay with that in a competitive PvP game.

Don’t even compare musket and hatchet for the love of god. Hatchet has to calculate bullet drop and is a projectile. While musket doesn’t need to calculate anything its just point and click.
Musket is by far the easiest weapon to play in the game (maybe lifestaff is close too).

@Kippp

The spear might have a generous hit box with javelin, but I haven’t really tested it

It does, still javelin toss isn’t a core skill either, it has it’s niche but it isn’t as good as skewer or perforate for instance. People mainly use it to 1v1 for make some youtube videos.

[Kippp]

@igor.castro.nogueira

But it does LOL heavies have extended hitboxes, while lights doesn’t. So a more accurate comparison should compare bow’s lights and throwing hatchets light, since it doesn’t have a heavy atack mode.

Having huge hit boxes is not normal in any competitive PvP game.

You want huge hit boxes in pve? Sure.

There is no justification for it in PvP. It is something that lowers the skill floor for the weapon that allows anyone to use it effectively.

[igor.castro.nogueira]

@Kippp

Having huge hit boxes is not normal in any competitive PvP game.

Well, i kinda agree with that, but still if that’s the case we should nerf every ranged weapon because RIGHT NOW bow has less hitbox than most ranged projectile weapons (hatchet excluded for obvious reasons)

[Kippp]

You should have to actually hit the character model with all range weapons.

This is not some crazy/controversial idea.

The balance would likely be almost fine if you actually had to hit your target.

Alternatively, I guess you could expand melee weapon’s hit boxes to allow melee weapons to miss their target by about a meter, but that would be insane and ridiculous, right?

[igor.castro.nogueira]

I’m not sure what you’re talking about ‘-’.

I mean first you said that bow had extended hitboxes, which i explained it wasn’t the case when compared to ANY other ranged weapon (hatchet excluded because it’s a melee weapon)

Now you said that ranged weapons need a hitbox decrease, which i agree, but not only for bow since it already has lower hitbox on heavies compared to other ranged weapons.

Now you’re talking about buffing hitboxes for melee weapons which i honestly don’t follow, Since honing is from day 1 inserted in the game.

So i don’t follow whats the point you’re trying to make here.

[Nabrious]

@Glorfinhel
You’re grasping at straws, the 64% damage would be the damage I would have taken had I not had an insane amount of thrust protection applied.

Also you failed to prove or explain how insanely high damage is not OP. Saying an arrow can be dodged because you can see it is not an example. You can see everything. Except projectiles that are shot at you from off your screen, so if anything your own explanation proves you incorrect.

I have a job where I work 6 days a week and I play other games I actually have fun playing, sorry I was not able to acknowledge your non-answer to my question earlier.

I am speaking only to the damage and hitboxes of bow, which I believe 4000 hours of being shot at qualifies me quite well to speak on this matter.

Again you’re grasping at straws by literally taking my own retort and attempting to re-use it with poor sentence structure with nonsense. Re-read your own sentence, its literally just words, there is no actual meaning behind it because there is no sentence structure, so your point is lost in the abyss of misguided words you spewed and regurgitated.

---

@igor.castro.nogueira
Firestaff also has similar issues as bow, but not nearly as bad. You cant use one thing to justify another. They’re both in the wrong.

I stand by my words that if a healer cannot out heal the damage of 1 dps it negates the entire point of a healer. 1 good healer should ALWAYS be able to out-heal the damage of 1 good dps.

Projectiles I cannot see are projectiles off my screen, such as behind me, to my far left or far right. I’m not complaining about taking damage from them in this instance, just that I don’t think I should be staggered by something I cannot see, so an example would be me casting a heal, and getting staggered by a bow from behind that I could not see and cannot reasonably be expected to dodge out of the way from.

If anything healers have more shiz to deal with than most any other character (except maybe a melee whos always in the thick of it) My reasoning is we have 5 more buttons than any other class to deal with targeted healing, and we have to watch everyone’s health, our health and debuffs, and our positioning, and our teams positioning, and the enemies positioning, and other healers sacreds, and enemy sacreds, and our teams cc’s and enemy teams cc’s. To say healers playing the game right now don’t know how to play the game means you clearly have not encountered a skilled healer yet on your server. Maybe its time to transfer to a better server.

I almost never drop sacred on myself unless I know im out of stamina, or wont be able to dodge incoming cc. So the fact that you’re assuming im a bot healer means you’re just offended about something I called you out on, so you’re lashing out at me for having less skill because I might use some of my own healing abilities on myself… lol what a joke you are.

---

You both have again proven my point that forums are the worst possible form of feedback, because of sensitive angry forum dwellers such as yourselves.

This thread has devolved into just throwing insults at one another’s intelligence and skill. which does not help anyone in any way. I give the forums an F for a huge waste of my time.