You are one of the people who says you don’t know, but you do know lol, you even state what is a Fresh start server, A few google search will even tell you what it is, But anyways…
It does matter, If you want New and Returning players to join back into the game.
The Problem is, they need to make sure this time people stay, Most Majority of people left because of the Duplicates and how items become way cheaper when obviously The market plunged way down and too fast.
Just imagine working time and effort to just realize somewhere out there people can make dupes.
Now this effects the Guild Leaders and its Members, eventually it spreads like a Corona Virus, when members start quitting the community gets effected, Like a domino effect, Hence the massive people quitting and moving on.
Now I don’t care if you say the dupes have been removed, But that’s up to the majority of the community to decide, Most case scenario, no they don’t believe and the damage is there and there’s a potential leak and missed dupes lingering around.
Tho the small bugs and exploits followed by Bots a small shank to the people, The dupes was the one that nailed it to the coffin.
The funny thing is the complainers about a new “Fresh Start Server” They are the people who tend want to drag everyone else with them, They are the Hoarders of resources, The people who like to show boat/ Flex those such resources, The ones that possible abused such advantage in secret, Only to find out there’s a new server that doesn’t allow transfers to it.
You don’t get to choose who stays and who leaves, The majority of people are sheep’s and will follow the domino effect, people will follow the crowd, They want to restart the adventure and the appeal of doing it fair.
There will always be Two servers open in New World, One the Old/Legacy and One the New.
If the The Old and New servers end up merging again in the future, Then the point of bringing people back into the game would have already failed, and most majority on the community would have quit again.
Why does it matter? “IT IS TO BRING PEOPLE BACK INTO THE GAME”
If they don’t fix the unfair play, Bots, Bugs, etc including dupe potential, then there is no point to creating a “New Fresh Start Server”
Hopefully they learnt from the past and this is a “Turn a New leaf” is the final Result of a solid foundation for New World.